A will is supposed to be the clearest expression of a person’s wishes. Once you do that, all that is left is to sign your name and move on. But when families end up in court fighting over whether a will should stand, the discussion almost always starts with a tricky question that no one wants to ask. Is it possible for someone to be unfit to make a will, and if so, how?
This question comes up more often than people realize.
Aging parents. Sudden changes to long-standing estate plans.
Estranged relatives who reappear late in life.
When emotions are already running high, doubts about mental clarity or outside influence can turn a private family matter into a full-blown legal dispute. Determining whether someone was unfit to make a will is rarely a yes-or-no matter. The law focuses on a person’s capacity, not assumptions, and it asks different questions than most people expect. Looking at those questions helps explain why some wills are successfully challenged, while others are upheld—even under difficult circumstances.
At the center of that analysis is a legal principle that shapes every capacity dispute: testamentary capacity.
What Is “Testamentary Capacity”?
In estate planning law, the ability to make or update a will is measured by something called “testamentary capacity.” It is not a medical diagnosis, and it is not the same as being mentally sharp in every area of life. Instead, it is a legal threshold that focuses on whether a person understands what they are doing when they sign their will.
Testamentary capacity does not require perfect memory, flawless reasoning, or freedom from all mental health challenges.
Many people who struggle with illness, aging, or cognitive decline can still have the legal capacity to make a valid will. What matters is whether they can grasp the document’s significance and make decisions that reflect their own intentions.
Testamentary capacity is evaluated at the moment the will is executed, not weeks or months before or after. A person may be confused on some days and perfectly lucid on others. The law recognizes this reality, which is why disputes often turn on evidence tied to a very specific point in time.
Understanding the requirements that make up testamentary capacity helps clarify where courts draw the line.
The Legal Requirements for Testamentary Capacity
The legal phrasing may vary from one jurisdiction to another, but the underlying approach is consistent. Courts break down a person’s fitness into a few practical concerns, each aimed at understanding how clearly the person grasped the situation and the choices they were making.
- Do they understand that they are making a will and what that means?
The person must know that they are creating or updating a legal document that controls how their estate will be distributed after death. They do not need to know every legal term, but they must understand the purpose and effect of signing the document. - Are they aware of the general nature and extent of their property?
This does not require a detailed inventory or exact dollar amounts. Instead, the person must have a reasonable awareness of what they own—such as real estate, financial accounts, or other significant assets—and that those assets will be affected by the will. - Do they recognize the “natural objects of their bounty?”
This phrase refers to the people who would ordinarily be expected to inherit, such as a spouse, children, or close family members. Importantly, the person does not have to leave assets to these individuals. They simply must be aware of who they are and consciously decide whether, and how, to include them. The law is concerned with awareness, not approval. - Are they free from delusions that influence the distribution of the estate
The law distinguishes eccentric beliefs and fixed false beliefs that directly shape the terms of a will. If a decision is driven by a delusion, such as believing a child is stealing money when there is no basis for it, that connection can undermine the will’s validity.
When these elements come together, courts are generally inclined to uphold a will, even if the choices seem unfair, surprising, or emotionally charged. Problems arise when one or more of these abilities are missing or when external factors interfere with the decision-making process.
Conditions That Can Render Someone Unfit to Make a Will
Fitness to make a will is purely fact-specific. That said, courts frequently see certain conditions in will contests because they raise legitimate concerns about a person’s judgment, awareness, or independence.
- Cognitive impairment that includes dementia or Alzheimer’s disease
Certain neuro-cognitive disorders can often interfere with memory, reasoning, and comprehension. However, the diagnosis alone is not enough to legally invalidate a will. Many individuals will experience periods of clarity, sometimes called “lucid intervals,” during which they still meet the legal standard for fitness. The key question is whether the will was signed during one of those periods. - Severe mental illness affecting perception or belief
Mental illness does not disqualify someone from making a will. The issue arises when delusions or hallucinations directly shape estate decisions. If a will is based on false beliefs that have no grounding in reality and those beliefs influence who receives property, courts may find the document unreliable. - Intoxication or substance impairment at the time of signing
Alcohol or drug use can temporarily impair judgment and understanding. A will executed while a person is under the influence may be challenged if the substance use interfered with their ability to comprehend what they were doing or to make independent decisions. - Undue influence by another individual
Even when someone has some degree of fitness, a will can be invalid if it results from coercion, manipulation, or pressure. This often involves a person in a position of trust who benefits from sudden or drastic changes to the estate plan.
These situations are rarely obvious on the surface. They tend to emerge through patterns, timing, and behavior that only become clear after someone has passed away. That uncertainty is precisely why planning matters.
Steps That Can Help Protect a Will From Being Challenged
While no estate plan is entirely immune from dispute, there are practical measures that significantly reduce the risk of a successful challenge. These steps help create a clear record of intent and capacity at the time the will is executed.
Having a medical evaluation performed around the time the will is signed can be helpful in some situations, especially if there are known health concerns. A doctor’s report does not settle every dispute, but it does give courts something concrete to consider. That record ties the signing to a specific point in time, rather than to assumptions later made from unrelated appointments or secondhand accounts.
Choosing disinterested witnesses is also a good idea. Witnesses who do not benefit from the will and who can later testify about the testator’s clarity, awareness, and demeanor provide valuable third-party confirmation that the signing was legitimate.
Adding a Self-Proving Affidavit to a will is another way to protect it. This is simply a notarized document attached to the will that records the signing and confirms everyone involved understood what they were doing at the time. It can make things easier later because courts can refer to the affidavit instead of tracking down witnesses again. Beyond that, it provides additional reassurance that the process was carried out correctly and in accordance with the testator’s intentions, helping prevent disputes or delays during probate.
While not universally recommended, a video recording of the signing can further demonstrate that the person understood what they were doing and acted voluntarily. It can also capture tone, responsiveness, and demeanor in a way written records cannot, offering additional context if the circumstances are later questioned.
Above all, having an experienced estate planning attorney involved can make a real difference. They handle the details, make sure everything is documented correctly, and keep the process on track. Even small steps like timing, signatures, and proper witnessing matter a lot later on, and having a professional guide things can prevent misunderstandings or disputes later.
Estate Planning Matters
Mental fitness concerns during a will execution do not always announce themselves in the most obvious ways. These types of problems tend to emerge slowly. Changes in health, family dynamics, and other personal circumstances often shape them. When the objective is clarity rather than conflict, and certainty rather than second-guessing, thoughtful estate planning is not just helpful; it’s essential.
Working with a capable estate planning attorney helps bring structure to the entire process, ensuring a person’s will reflects what the person truly wanted and leaves little room for doubt later.
Call Nelson Law Group Today!!
When it comes to protecting your family’s future for years down the road, it is imperative to have an estate planning attorney in your corner at all times. Give our knowledgeable staff here at Nelson Law Group, PC, a call if you have any questions. Our staff is always available.
For more information about Brett A. Nelson, click here.
